Categories

Archives

Which Siding Should I Choose?


February 22nd, 2012
Alex Lee, Energy Engineer

There are several different kinds of siding options for homeowners to choose from. The most popular types are vinyl siding and fiber cement siding. Both are durable and do not rot over time.  Also, the use of vinyl sidings or fiber cement sidings will not lead to any infestation-related issues.  Most importantly, they can help retain heat inside your homes and thus help reduce your energy bills.

There are however significant differences between vinyl sidings and fiber cement sidings. Vinyl sidings are mostly made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), which is a synthetic material that is essentially plastic.  As a result, it is already colored, and homeowners or installers are not required to paint them.  What a convenience!  Since vinyl siding is basically made of plastic, it is affordable, recyclable, and impact resistant.  Think about an empty plastic water bottle; it is cheap to produce, recyclable, and never breaks no matter how many times you drop it or throw it against a wall.

However, the properties of plastic lead to drawbacks for vinyl sidings.  When vinyl sidings are exposed to fires, they can melt and release toxic fumes, which are environmentally hazardous and potentially fatal to homeowners.  Also, in response to temperature, they contract and expand.  As a result, this continuous bending can potentially cause vinyl sidings to crack.  In addition, since they are already colored, which provides a convenience of not going through the painting hassle, this advantage can lead to a disadvantage.  Over time, the color will wear off, and vinyl sidings cannot be repainted, since their contraction and expansion can cause paint to chip off.  But a combined use of urethane and acrylic based paints has recently shown to solve this problem with their adhesive properties.

Meanwhile, fiber cement sidings are mostly composed of cement, sand, cellulose fibers such as the ones derived from wood, and ash.  They have been used for over 100 years for home-building.  This is a good indicator that homeowners have been satisfied with it, and there are several reasons why that is the case.  Fiber cement siding is extremely durable, even during harsh weather conditions.  It is also not affected by salt or UV rays.  The properties of strength and durability are from the cellulose fibers that help prevent cracks from forming.  Also, fiber cement sidings have a more natural look in terms of its wood texture as opposed to vinyl siding.  They are required to be painted, but they provide the flexibility of choosing any color that you desire.  The color from the paint in fiber cement sidings last 3-4 times more than the one in wood sidings; in fact, it can last for up to 25 years.  In addition, fiber cement sidings are fire-resistant, and currently, they do not contain any materials that release toxic fumes.  Hence, while they look like wood, at the same time, they act like bricks.

Despite their many advantages, fiber cement sidings have a major drawback of their high initial costs.  During their production, they consume high amounts of energy, and they cost much more to produce than vinyl sidings.  Also, it is more difficult for installers to install them.  During their installation, fiber cement sidings release high amounts of dust, and safety precautions need to be taken to avoid dust inhalation.  Hence, along with higher material costs, labor costs are also higher compared to vinyl sidings.  Furthermore, fiber cement sidings can be brittle.  Imagine that you throw a thin piece of concrete up in the air, and as soon as it hits the ground, you will likely witness many small pieces of concrete flying everywhere.

Thus, the ideal choice of home sidings depends on your preferences as vinyl sidings and fiber cement sidings have their own advantages and disadvantages in terms of energy efficiency, cost effectiveness, sustainability, and aesthetic appeal.  If you have a low to medium budget and you want to avoid the hassle of painting, vinyl sidings may be a better choice. But if you have a medium to high budget, durability is paramount, and you prefer a more natural, wood-like texture, then go for the fiber cement siding.  Also, another good word of advice: hire well-trained, professional installers to do the job for you, especially if you prefer fiber cement sidings. Needless to say, siding is one of the most important aspects of your home’s visual appeal and it is an essential part of optimizing your home’s performance, so you want to make sure you get it done the right way.